FDO RFC 35 - Support Data Store level FDO capabilities

This page contains an change request (RFC) for the FDO Open Source project. More FDO RFCs can be found on the RFCs page.

Status

RFC Template Version	(1.0)
Submission Date	June 08, 2009
Last Modified	Dan StoicaTimestamp
Author	Dan Stoica, Orest Halustchak
RFC Status	draft
Implementation Status	draft
Proposed Milestone	3.5.0.0
Assigned PSC guide(s)	Greg Boone
Voting History
+1
+0
-0
-1

Overview

This RFC is for changing the behavior of FdoIConnection::GetXCapabilities().

Motivation

There are cases where a provider indicates support of a capability that is actually not supported by a data store the provider may connect to. For example, if an Oracle data store is not prepared for locking, this functionality is not supported in that data store although the provider itself is capable of providing the functionality. ODBC also can connect to a variety of sources, each with varying levels of capability. Or there are cases where a user connected to a data store may not have the permission to write. This may be because the data store has a read-only flag (SHP, SDF) or a user has not been granted permissions to write to a data store (RDBMS). In this case, the information the provider level capability SupportsWrite returns is incorrect.

Proposed Solution

Change the behavior of GetXCapabilities(). On an open connection it will retrieve the exact capabilities, specific for that database. On a closed connection the current behavior will be preserved and provider level capabilities will be returned.

Note another solution has been considered. It consists in adding a flag on each GetXCapabilities() method, like:

FDO_API virtual FdoIConnectCapabilities *GetConnectionCapabilities(bool dataStoreLevel = false) = 0;

This alternative suggests that might be cases when a less accurate response is preferred over the exact one. Therefore it is unlikely 2 signatures are needed.

Implications

Several cases have been identified so far as good candidates for improvements:

SQLite, SDF, SHP: fix SupportsWrite() capability for the case of read-only files.
MySQL: depends on the storage driver; fix GetCommands() to indicate apply schema is only supported if FDO metadata.
ODBC: we officially support 6-7 data sources and we need to check all the capabilities.
Oracle: Oracle Express does not support long transactions. Fix GetCommands() so it doesn't return long transaction related commands.

Test Plan

Existing provider units tests to be enhanced to exercise the changes.

Funding/Resources

Autodesk to provide resources / funding.