wiki:GSoC/2018/FullSupportPython3

Version 24 (modified by sanjeet, 6 years ago) ( diff )

Added Week 13 final report

Full support of Python 3 in GRASS GIS

Title: Full support of Python 3 in GRASS GIS
Student Name: Sanjeet Bhatti
Organization: ​OSGeo - Open Source Geospatial Foundation
Mentor Name: Anna Petrášová and Luca Delucchi
GSoC proposal: ​View proposal
Link to code: ​Code Repository

Abstract

The current GRASS GIS version has partial support for Python 3. This project aims to update core GRASS components for Python 3 and update all the python modules, libraries and components like script package, python/ctypes, pygrass, temporal, wxGUI, etc. At the end of this project, GRASS GIS will be compatible with both the versions of python, i.e Python 2.7 and Python 3 with its GUI having support for wxPython 4.

Timeline

Time Period

Milestones

Tasks

Status

April 23 - May 14
Community Bonding

  • Introduction to Community
  • Create Wiki page
  • Set up code repository
  • Add links to community wiki pages
  • Set up development environment
  • Discussion with mentors about the libraries tests for the project
  • Get familiar with the testing framework
  • Update current tests of the python script library, adjust them to work with Python3
  • Get familiar with the overall working of GRASS GIS and understand Python dependencies in the system
  • Read documentation
  • Practice fixing bugs
Done

May 14 - May 20
Week 1

  • Dealing with Unicode & binary data (encoding and decoding).
  • Setting up the foundation for porting the main libraries and components

Done

May 21 - May 27
Week 2

Porting script package module and its dependencies

Done

May 28 - June 3
Week 3

  • Porting other scripts and small libraries
  • Write tests to check the consistency of libs subsequent to the changes

Done

June 4 - June 10
Week 4

  • Finish pending work for this phase, if any.
  • Doing some research on ctypesgen and pygrass
  • Preparing and testing the changes for the evaluation

Done

July 11 - July 15
Evaluation 1

  • Evaluation of work done in the previous phase
  • Next phase discussions

Done

June 11 - June 17
Week 5

  • Incorporate any changes, as necessary, from the discussions and feedback
  • Work on Porting ctypes module

Done

June 18 - June 24
Week 6

Porting pygrass module and its dependencies

June 25 - July 1
Week 7

  • Porting temporal module and its dependencies
  • Porting remaining libs and their dependencies

July 2 - July 8
Week 8

  • Finish pending work for this phase, if any.
  • Preparing and testing the changes for the evaluation

July 9 - July 13
Evaluation 2

  • Evaluation of work done in the previous phase
  • Next phase discussions

July 9 - July 29
Week 9-11

  • Based on the feedback, make necessary changes
  • Writing additional classes in wrap.py for updating wxGUI to be compatible with both wxPython 3 and 4.
  • Finish porting to Python 3
  • Fixing all deprecated messages
  • Testing the changes.

July 30 - August 5
Week 12

  • Preparing and testing all the changes
  • Writing documentation for the final evaluation

August 6 - August 14
Evaluation 3 (Final)

  • Final code submission
  • Evaluation of final submission

Community Bonding Period Report

During the Community Bonding Period I performed the following activities:

Introduction to Community
I wrote an introductory email to the SoC mailing list and grass-dev mailing list and gave a description about my project and shared my wiki page, public repository, and project proposal links.

Create Wiki page
I requested the write access to setup a project wiki page. Then, I created my wiki page detailing the project description, containing link to my GSoC application, a detailed timeline, link to my public repository where all my commits and progress can be followed.

Set up code repository
I have setup my code repository on github for tracking the applied changesets.

Set up development environment
I setup my development environment (Ubuntu 18.04) for two Python versions (Python 2.7.x and Python 3.6.x) for which I am using virtual environments. This was done because I need to make sure that when I update any code it should be compatible with both the versions.

Add links to community wiki pages
I added my project links to the OSGeo's Google Summer of Code 2018 Accepted students wiki page and trac wiki page: ​https://wiki.osgeo.org/wiki/Google_Summer_of_Code_2018_Accepted and ​https://trac.osgeo.org/grass/wiki/GSoC.

Discussion with mentors about the libraries tests for the project
I got in touch with my mentors to discuss the right approach to test the code and submit files. We discussed about the python libraries and their testsuites, starting with Python script library.

Get familiar with the testing framework
I followed the wiki page to get familiar with the testing framework(​https://grasswiki.osgeo.org/wiki/GRASS_and_Python). I also followed the grass Python Scripting tutorials from this link: ​https://github.com/wenzeslaus/python-grass-addon

Update current tests of the python script library, adjust them to work with Python3
I updated the code in the python script library to make it work on Python3 and submitted the patch files for those. I used the standard North Carolina dataset that uses the basic version of the dataset. (https://grass.osgeo.org/download/sample-data/) I have looked through the summary reports for the current tests of GRASS which is going to be useful when I will update tests for the libraries in the system. (​http://fatra.cnr.ncsu.edu/grassgistests/summary_report/)

Get familiar with the overall working of GRASS GIS and understand Python dependencies in the system
I went through the GRASS wiki pages to get familiar with the working of the system (https://grass.osgeo.org/grass75/manuals/libpython/) and looked through the source code. Also, I found the code dependencies that I will be working with throughout the coding period.

Read documentation
I read some documentation related to GSoC guidelines about working throughout the GSoC period. I also read GRASS GIS Python library documentation: (https://grass.osgeo.org/grass75/manuals/libpython/)

Practice fixing bugs
I wrote a bug fix related to wxPython(​https://trac.osgeo.org/grass/ticket/3510) during Pre-bonding period and submitted the patch file.

Weekly reports

Week 1

What did I complete this week?

  • Updated the script for redundant lines in the patch submitted for utils.py
  • Tested the patches on Python versions 2.7.x, 3.5.x and 3.6.x
  • Read and understood the main differences about Strings, Unicode strings and Byte strings in Python 2 and 3 versions. Wrote some brief differences for quick reference(​https://docs.google.com/document/d/18Tvl0vpTSwOfO4xGKXpAo-h6o6WAAZmHX8neYIsHTtA)
  • Read python's package futurize's documentation for Py2 to Py3 conversion
  • Updated source code in python lib files (uncommitted, still testing)

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • Finish porting 'script' library to support Python3
  • Test the changes for both the versions
  • Implement any tests required for testing

Is there any blocking issue?

Not at the moment.

Week 2

What did I complete this week?

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • Write more tests for script library to test the changes
  • Look into the issue of running scripts for Python 3.5 and Python 3.6 (some tests fail on either of the versions)
  • Port other small libraries and scripts

Is there any blocking issue?

Not at the moment.

Week 3

What did I complete this week?

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • After discussion and feedback from the mentors, finish pending work
  • Look into ctypes and pygrass libraries
  • Discuss with mentors about possible solutions for ctypes
  • Test all the changes done for the evaluation period

Is there any blocking issue?

Not at the moment.

Week 4

What did I complete this week?

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • Submit the first evaluation
  • Work on any changes necessary after discussion and feedback from the mentors
  • Start working on porting the ctypes library

Is there any blocking issue?

Not at the moment.

Week 5

What did I complete this week?

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • Work on 'pygrass' module
  • Compare changes of ctypes compiled version among all 3 versions with and without changes
  • Write new tests for some of the remaining scripts in 'trunk/scripts'

Is there any blocking issue?

Not at the moment.

Week 6

What did I complete this week?

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • Continue working on 'pygrass' module
  • Work on 'temporal' library
  • Fix pending issues in pygrass

Is there any blocking issue?

Not at the moment.

Week 7

What did I complete this week?

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • Start exploring GUI library, starting with mapdisp and imgr
  • Continue working on fixing ctypes module
  • Continue working on 'temporal' library

Is there any blocking issue?

Ctypes are not fully compatible with the Python3 even if they are compiling without any issues. Discussed with mentors about the next steps and how to deal with ctypes. Will discuss more about the upcoming milestones and how ctypes handling is to be done so as not to interfere too much with the pending work.

Week 8

What did I complete this week?

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • Fix deprecated code in GUI library
  • Keep working on ctypes-pygrass-temporal libraries
  • Write tests for trunk/scripts

Is there any blocking issue?

Not at the moment.

Week 9

What did I complete this week?

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • Fix deprecated code in GUI library
  • Fix other gui command files
  • Keep working on temporal library
  • Test all the reamining files in temporal testsuite

Is there any blocking issue?

Not at the moment.

Week 10

What did I complete this week?

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • Replace remaining code deprecated warnings in GUI library
  • Fix remaining gui command files
  • Work on forms.py to fix string errors
  • Replace all instances of old wx.* code with wrapper classes where suitable

Is there any blocking issue?

Not at the moment.

Week 11

What did I complete this week?

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • Fix assertion errors
  • Fix remaining warnings in GUI library
  • Do testing for GUI
  • Prepare for evaluation, prepare deliverables

Is there any blocking issue?

Not at the moment.

Week 12

What did I complete this week?

What am I going to achieve for the next week?

  • Do more testing, and fix bugs and errors
  • Prepare deliverables, update all patches with the latest revision
  • Prepare guidelines for Py2/3 compatibility code
  • Write Final Report

Is there any blocking issue?

Not at the moment.

Week 13 - Final Report

Title: Full support of Python 3 in GRASS GIS
Community: GRASS GIS - OSGeo

Abstract:
This project updates the GRASS GIS software to support Python 3, where earlier it only worked with Python 2.7 version. All the libraries, modules and components of the system have been updated to include the latest changes that have been introduced in Python 3. One of the important updates was a way to deal with unicode and bytes strings that helped in making GRASS compatible with both the versions of Python by properly encoding and decoding the strings. Additionally, the ctypes library, which was only working with Python 2.7, has been upgraded to deal with Python 3 which further helped in modifying the temporal and pygrass libraries. The pydispatch and guinittest modules has also been altered to properly deal with unicodes while the trunk/scripts have been modified and tested by writing new testsuites for them. The GUI module of GRASS is built with wxPython Classic version, which now with the help of wrapper classes works well with the latest wxPython 4 - Phoenix version.

The state of the art BEFORE start of GSoC:
Before the start of the project, GRASS GIS had partial support for Python 3. The ctypes library failed to compile with Python 3 whereas a lot of code in other modules was incompatible with Python 3 syntax. The GUI module worked with wxPython 3 (Classic version) but not with the latest wxPython 4 (Phoenix). There were lot of assertion errors and deprecated code warnings that were seen when GRASS was coupled with the wxPython 4.

The state of the art AFTER GSoC:
After the GSoC, GRASS can now be compiled with Python 3 version. The different libraries and components of GRASS have been updated and are thus compilable with Python 3.
The GUI module now has support for both the versions of wxPython, i.e. Classic (3 or older) and Phoenix (4).

Challenges:
The biggest challenge in updating GRASS was dealing with the ‘ctypes’ library. The official library has not been updated since some time now and the Python 3 support is not complete. It was a major hurdle to get it working in GRASS to compile other modules/libraries that are dependent on the ‘ctypes’. After making the desired changes in the library, the GRASS system is able to compile but there are some lingering issues that make it hard to fix the issues that persist in the temporal and pygrass libraries.

Next Steps:
The next step would be to discuss ‘ctypes’ issue in further detail with mentors and the development community. Even though some issues related to ctypes have been solved in this project, it still requires some significant efforts and time to make it fully compatible with all Python versions. Moreover, fixing ctypes will help in solving all the remaining issues in other GRASS modules that are closely dependent on this library.

Permanent Links:
Code Repository for GSoC:
​https://github.com/sanjeetbhatti/FullSupportPython3

Weekly Reports:
​https://trac.osgeo.org/grass/wiki/GSoC/2018/FullSupportPython3

Python 2 - 3 and wxPython compatibility guidelines for developers:
​https://trac.osgeo.org/grass/wiki/Python3Support

Image for project representation:
​https://raw.githubusercontent.com/sanjeetbhatti/FullSupportPython3/master/GSoC-final-report-project-pic.png

Note: See TracWiki for help on using the wiki.